WTI and Brent may have lost some from the run they had since early November, but even though oil is a bit lower than the 10-month high set recently, the curve provides some good value as it stands, without having to resort to options structures.
We have recommended using swaps as the default structure for hedging oil through mid-2021 tenors because of fundamental worries, but now the swaps are wise because of opportunity.
We reiterate the recommendation to use swaps for any baseline, protective hedges through mid-2021. However, it is good timing to reach out farther into the curve and lock in these prices, not just for the near-term, but through 2022 if you are behind schedule on your hedges.
Short-term risks are too numerous to recommend using collars. With Brent around $50, we doubt OPEC+'s commitment to withholding supply. Hedging activity at AEGIS has increased with this vertical shift in the curve, implying higher realized prices for producers and more drilling activity. The U.S. dollar's weakness has artificially increased prices and could reverse. Consult the AEGIS Factor Matrix, available via the AEGIS online platform, for a full discussion.
Toward late 2021, collars may make more sense for many as some supply-demand risks fade. But the collar is not a perfect choice. Consider the Cap/Floor Index we discuss here, which shows how collars require the producer to sacrifice more upside than is "fair."